It's Daya Keane's junior year, and nothing is as she expected. First, her mother has started attending Grace Redeemer, the popular megachurch in town. Boasting concert-worthy light shows, an amazing live band--and a pastor who's all about loving thy neighbor, as long as thy neighbor "gets right with God" first. And second, Daya talks to Beckett Wild at a party neither of them were meant to be at. Beckett is Daya''s longtime crush, the one she's been pining after for years. She's smart, cute, artistic--and the apparent poster girl for Grace Redeemer's popular youth program. As Daya's best friends, Stella and B'Rad, are quick to point out, someone like Beckett wouldn't be remotely interested in returning her feelings. Except maybe she is. Except maybe she does. Daya's never felt the need to have "normal" high school experiences. But she never expected to fall this hard for someone, either. Now Daya has to decide how far she's willing to surrender to Beckett's world of Grace Redeemer, and who she's willing to become to be with her.