Annabelle Blake is prepared for sixth grade to be fairly uneventful, but everything changes when she meets Bailey, a nonbinary new student who Annabelle develops her first crush on. Annabelle thinks Bailey is super great, and she enjoys hearing about their life in Seattle, meeting their entertaining parents, and hanging out at their massive house. But Annabelle's world is turned even more upside down when her father tells her that he and Bailey have something in common. When she learns how her community is not as welcoming as she thought, she is inspired to stand up for Bailey, her father, and other members of the LGBTQ+ community.