Jay Collier, the only out gay kid in his small Washington town, compiles a romantic list of all the things he hopes to one day experience, calling it his "Gay Agenda." He wants to meet another gay kid, fall in love with a boy, and lose his virginity among other things. When his family moves to Seattle, and Jay starts his senior year at a high school with a large LGBTQIA+ group, he finally feels like he belongs. But as he starts crossing things off his list, life becomes complicated.