One morning at River Point, five boys go out hunting, only four come back, and none of the survivors will say which of them it was who killed their friend, Grant. High school senior Kate Marino, interning at the district attorney's office just for something to put on her college application, finds herself roped into the investigation when her boss asks for her help in sweeping the case under the rug to protect the affluent River Point Boys. Kate won't let that happen, and decides to dig up secrets about each of the four boys, and she discovers that the hunting accident may have been no accident at all.