Finn, Livia, Ever, Carter, and Maddie have a tradition of playing a murder mystery game at Livia's family cabin. But each of them are dealing with their own demons. Finn doesn't trust anyone since he was attacked a few months ago. Livia saw the attack and did nothing to stop it. Maddy was in an accident that destroyed her sports career, Carter is struggling under his family's expectations, and Ever wants to keep the game going at all costs. But when they gather for one last game, the line between reality and the game begin to blur as it becomes clear that someone is out to get rid of them.